What If AI Knows You Better Than You Know Yourself?

Written By Maryama Elmi

The Rise of AI Companionship

When you first wake up in the morning and check your phone, your AI assistant has already curated your daily news feed, suggested a playlist that matches your mood, and recommended a product you didn’t realize you wanted. Your online experience is perfectly curated to you. But what if it’s more than that? What if AI doesn’t just predict your preferences but understands you better than you understand yourself?

Recent years have marked the rise of AI companions. These systems have become more than just simple assistants; they now can craft interactions that mimic genuine human connection. Time and The New York Times have reported, AI bots are becoming more and more ‘real’, to the point that individuals are using AI as replacements for human relationships. But as these systems grow more sophisticated, the line between authentic connection and algorithmic influence starts to blur.

Beyond technical AI companionship, it is even more common for people to use systems like ChatGPT as a friend. Many individuals turn to AI for casual conversation, emotional support, or even guidance during tough times. These interactions can feel deeply personal. AI, drawing on vast amounts of data and predictive algorithms, can mirror the language, tone, and emotional cues that people seek in relationships. It offers a sense of validation and immediate connection, which can be comforting, especially in moments of loneliness or stress.

Relationships: How could AI affect human connection?

Imagine an AI predicting relationship conflicts before they arise or offering scripted advice during an argument. Could hyper-personalized AI help us connect better with others, or would it replace genuine emotional labor with artificial mediation?

On the one hand, AI could act as a neutral third party, reducing the emotional intensity of conflicts and facilitating healthy discussions. This kind of guidance could potentially lead to stronger connections by helping individuals avoid misunderstandings or hurt feelings. However, the darker side of this convenience is that AI’s advice could replace real emotional labor, causing people to miss out on developing the emotional skills needed to navigate the complexities of human relationships due to over-reliance on AI.

In Japan, AI-driven romantic partners have become a reality. Replika AI users have reported feeling attached to their AI companions, and even preferring their AI companions over human relationships, reflecting the growing emotional bond between humans and technology. But if AI understands us better than our loved ones, could it discourage real human connection rather than enhance it?

The Illusion of Autonomy

AI can be a revolutionary tool for self-reflection, mental health support, and decision-making. It can help us identify patterns in our emotions, see things from different perspectives and encourage us to make healthier choices. However, too much reliance on AI for emotional support can become unhealthy (see this article). Instead of being a tool that makes us better, it can become a tool that weakens our ability to navigate emotions independently, making us dependent on algorithmic validation rather than genuine human connection.

In extreme cases, AI has already shown devastating impacts. Reports of AI-driven chatbots exacerbating mental health crises and even encouraging harmful behavior highlight the dangers of unchecked AI influence. If algorithms know our vulnerabilities, how do we ensure they don’t exploit them?

The fundamental question remains: If AI knows us better than we know ourselves, how do we protect the core of our autonomy? 

Ethical Impacts of AI on Mental Health

AI isn’t just shaping individual experiences—it’s increasingly influencing critical areas of society. As we recognize its personal impact, we must also examine how it’s being deployed in fields like mental health, where the consequences can be extreme and profound.

For example, AI-driven mental health tools could make therapy more accessible to those in need. However, if designed irresponsibly, they risk becoming mass-market self-help products that prioritize engagement over real well-being. This can lead to harmful consequences, including self-harm, isolation, and even worsening mental health issues (see this article for a deeper dive).

Further, businesses stand to benefit enormously from AI-driven mental health tools, particularly those that prioritize user engagement over true well-being. Subscription-based therapy apps, AI chatbots, and self-help platforms can generate significant revenue, especially if they keep users coming back. But if the focus shifts from genuinely helping people to maximizing profits, the risks become clear—AI could encourage dependency rather than healing, offering surface-level solutions while simultaneously neglecting deeper mental health needs.

This highlights the urgent need for ethical deployment. If AI is shaping such a personal and vulnerable aspect of human life, companies, policymakers, and other key stakeholders must prioritize safety, transparency, and real-world impact over profit. Otherwise, we risk creating systems that serve corporate interests at the expense of human well-being. 

These shifts aren’t happening in the distant future—they’re unfolding now. If we don’t critically assess how AI is being deployed in the domain of mental health, we risk allowing it to redefine human autonomy in ways we never consented to.

In other words, the question isn’t just what AI will do next, but who it will serve.

Conclusion

As AI systems become increasingly better at understanding and mimicking human behavior, this comes with significant risks. The more AI understands us, it can potentially shape our desires and decisions, cause harm to the most vulnerable, and erode our autonomy. As AI becomes more integrated into personal and social spheres, it may subtly influence our choices in ways we don't fully recognize, prioritizing corporate interests or profit-driven motives over individual well-being. This could lead to dependency on AI for emotional support or decision-making, weakening our ability to navigate the complexities of human experience independently. 

While AI’s predictive power can be used to enhance our personal lives and improve fields like mental health, we must remain vigilant about how this technology is deployed. Will we allow it to be a tool that empowers us, or will we let it redefine the very essence of who we are? Will we prioritize protecting those most vulnerable to its influence? 

References

Maryama Elmi
Previous

What if AI was a human right?
Next

Welcome to What If AI: Imagining the Future of Artificial Intelligence